Tax Implications in Relation to Withdrawal of Stock
Companies usually conduct various marketing and promotional activities to promote their products to existing as well as new customers. Due to the competitive business environment, companies may undertake several marketing approaches which include withdrawal of their trading stock as promotional items to be given to their customers. However, companies often overlook the tax implications in relation to their actions in withdrawing trading stock for business usage. Failure to comply with the tax legislation relating to withdrawal of stock may lead to additional tax payable by the companies.
Public Rulings (PR) on Tax Treatment of Stock in Trade
The Inland Revenue Board of Malaysia (IRBM) issued PR 4/2006 - Valuation of Stock in Trade and Work in Progress to highlight the tax implications when a person withdraws stock for own use without any consideration. The PR explained that the difference between the market value of the stock and the cost of the stock will be subject to tax in that particular year of assessment. In an example given in that PR, the stock withdrawn for the sole-proprietor’s friend’s wedding is taxable pursuant to Paragraph 24(2)(a) of the Income Tax Act, 1967 (ITA) as part of the gross income from the business.
In year 2020, the IRBM issued PR No. 3/2020 - Tax Treatment of Stock in Trade Part II - Withdrawal of Stock to specifically clarify the tax treatment of withdrawal of stock in trade pursuant to Sections 24(2) and 24(3) of the ITA. These PRs have defined stock in trade, whether moveable or immovable, to include the following:
(a) property sold in the ordinary course of the business or would be sold if it were mature or if its manufacture, preparation or construction were complete; or
(b) materials used in the manufacture, preparation or construction of any such property as referred to in paragraph (a) above and includes any work in progress.
The provisions of the ITA on withdrawal of stock are pursuant to Sections 24(2) and Section 24(3) of the ITA.
Section 24(2) of the ITA [Stock in trade withdrawn]
Where in the relevant period any stock in trade of a business of the relevant person is—
(a) withdrawn for his own use; or (b) withdrawn (otherwise than on requisition or compulsory acquisition or in a similar manner) without any consideration being received therefor or for a consideration consisting of—
(i) any property not being either a debt owing to the relevant person or a sum in cash or the equivalent of cash; (ii) any such property together with a debt owing to the relevant person or any such sum; or (iii) any such property together with a debt owing to the relevant person and any such sum,
then, subject to subsection (3), an amount equal to the market value of that stock in trade at the time of its withdrawal shall be treated as gross income of the relevant person from the business for the relevant period.
|
Public Rulings (PR) on Tax Treatment of Stock in Trade
Section 24(3) of the ITA [Consideration for stock in trade withdrawn]
Where in a case to which subsection (2) applies the consideration for the withdrawal of any stock in trade is consideration of the kind described in subparagraph (b)(ii) or (iii) of that subsection, then, for the purposes of that subsection—
(a) the amount of the market value of that stock in trade shall be reduced by the amount of the debt or sum or the amount of the debt and sum, as the case may be, referred to in whichever of those subparagraphs applies to the case;
(b) subsection (1) shall apply to the debt as if it were a debt arising on the sale of that stock in trade; and
(c) section 28 shall apply to any such sum. |
Withdrawal of stock is common in the property market. A property developer may transfer his trading stock (i.e. unsold properties) to fixed assets at the cost value. These properties may be rented out to derive rental income. In this scenario, the market value of the properties brought into account as fixed assets shall be treated as gross income of the property developer pursuant to Paragraph 24(2)(b) of the ITA.
Other than the above example, there are a few special scenarios in respect of withdrawal of stock in businesses. The following scenarios may be challenged by the IRBM during a tax audit if the appropriate tax treatment is not adopted.