Capital is a fact of life for many Partners in professional services firms. But how much capital should Partners contribute, how should that requirement be determined, and how should Partners fund it?
There is no single answer. Capital requirements vary significantly between firms depending on their size, business model, cashflow cycle and investment plans.
However, the starting point should be relatively simple: what capital does the business actually need?
A firm’s capital requirement should ultimately be driven by its underlying working capital needs.
That means looking beyond today's cash position. Firms should consider cashflow forecasts and future demands on working capital, including investment in technology, acquisitions, premises moves or refurbishment, partner retirements and other significant expenditure.
From this, the firm can establish an appropriate overall level of partner capital, including a sensible headroom.
A forward-looking approach also allows potential funding gaps to be identified early. That gives management and the firm time to consider how best to respond rather than having to seek additional capital from Partners at short notice.
Once the overall capital requirement has been established, simplicity has considerable advantages.
Firms may find it more practical to operate clearly defined capital bands.
For example:
The figures are illustrative. The appropriate amounts will depend on the particular firm's funding requirements.
An intermediate tier can be particularly useful for experienced lateral hires who, based on their seniority and experience, might ultimately be expected to reach the senior equity level but initially enter the partnership at a lower level.
Capital bands provide Partners with greater certainty and give the firm a transparent and relatively stable capital structure.
There can be a temptation to calculate each partner’s capital contribution as a percentage or multiple of their profit share, with Partners required to top up their capital as their profit allocation increases.
While superficially logical, this can result in capital contributions continually moving as individual profitability changes.
There are also tax considerations.
For LLPs within the salaried members legislation, an individual’s capital contribution can be relevant to Condition C. Firms should therefore be careful about arrangements under which capital contributions automatically change by reference to remuneration or profit allocation.
The firm's commercial need for capital should remain the starting point rather than allowing tax considerations to dictate an otherwise artificial capital structure.
The question of how much capital a firm requires is separate from how an individual partner chooses to fund their contribution.
It is well established for Partners to borrow from a bank to finance some or all of their partnership capital contribution. This means that joining a partnership, or moving to a higher capital tier, does not necessarily require the partner to fund the whole contribution from their existing personal resources.
Interest on borrowing used to finance a partner’s capital contribution usually qualifies for income tax relief.
This can make borrowing a practical and tax-efficient way of financing what can otherwise be a significant personal capital requirement.
However, the tax consequences should be reconsidered if the partner's capital contribution is subsequently reduced or capital is withdrawn.
Firms and Partners should therefore consider the tax position when capital arrangements change, rather than simply when the borrowing is first put in place.
Good capital management is ultimately about looking forward.
A firm that understands its future working capital needs can determine an appropriate overall level of partner funding, identify possible funding gaps early and plan how additional requirements will be met.
The objective should not be to maximise the amount of capital extracted from Partners. Nor should capital simply move up and down each year with individual profitability.
The better approach is a capital structure that is commercially justified, straightforward for Partners to understand and sufficiently flexible to support the firm's future plans.
Partnership capital should start with the needs of the business; a clear, forward-looking capital policy can provide the business with the funding it needs while giving Partners greater certainty about both the level of their commitment and how that commitment can be financed.
Partner capital provides long term funding for the business and can support its working capital requirements.
The appropriate level will depend on matters such as the firm's cashflow cycle, business model, investment plans and other available sources of finance.
The starting point should be the firm's actual and forecast working capital requirements, together with appropriate headroom for future needs.
Significant future expenditure, including technology investment, acquisitions, property costs and partner retirements, should also be factored into the assessment.
Not necessarily. A banded approach linked to partner status or seniority can provide a simpler and more stable structure than recalculating capital annually by reference to individual profit shares.
The appropriate approach will depend on the commercial circumstances of the individual firm.
Interest on borrowing used to fund a partner's capital contribution usually qualifies for income tax relief, there is a criteria that needs to be met.
Care is needed if capital is subsequently withdrawn or reduced, or if the use of the borrowing changes.
Potentially. An LLP member's capital contribution can be relevant to Condition C of the salaried members legislation.
Capital should therefore be considered as part of the firm's wider salaried members analysis, particularly where capital requirements are being introduced or changed.
There is no single timetable that will be appropriate for every firm. However, overall capital requirements should form part of regular cashflow and financial forecasting and should also be revisited when there is a material change in the business.
That might include an acquisition, significant technology investment, a premises move, changes in bank financing or movements in the partner population.