Transfer Pricing Implications of Intercompany Inventory Transfers

11/9/2026
Transfer Pricing Implications of Intercompany Inventory Transfers

Introduction

Supply-chain disruption, geopolitical uncertainty and inventory shortages frequently require multinational groups to redirect products between related entities. What may begin as an operational response to a temporary shortage can, however, create a significant transfer pricing question:

Can the inventory be transferred at cost, or should the supplying entity earn a return?

There is no automatic answer. Under the arm’s-length principle, the pricing must reflect what independent parties would have agreed in comparable circumstances. The analysis therefore depends not on the description of the transaction as an “inventory transfer,” but on its underlying commercial and economic characteristics.

A transfer at cost may be supportable in limited circumstances. In many other cases, the supplying entity may be entitled to compensation—not only for its activities and risks, but also for the commercial opportunity it gives up by transferring the inventory.


Look beyond the invoice price

The first step is to accurately delineate the transaction.

This requires understanding why the inventory was transferred, how it was sourced, which entity controlled the relevant risks and what alternatives were realistically available to each party.

Consider two different situations:

An entity procures products specifically at the request of a related party, takes no meaningful risk and simply facilitates the purchase.

An established distributor transfers inventory from its own stock, manages warehousing and logistics, bears obsolescence risk and potentially gives up sales to its own customers.

Although both transactions may be described as inventory transfers, their economic substance is materially different. A cost recharge may be plausible in the first scenario. It would generally be more difficult to support in the second.

The analysis should therefore begin with the operating reality, not with a predetermined preference for cost or cost plus.


When might a transfer at cost be defensible?

A transfer at cost may be supportable where the supplying entity’s role is genuinely limited and the arrangement is exceptional rather than part of its ordinary business model.

Relevant factors may include:

The transfer addresses a temporary and demonstrable shortage.

The products are procured specifically for the receiving entity rather than taken from the supplier’s normal commercial inventory.

The supplying entity does not perform material procurement, distribution, warehousing or market-development activities.

It does not assume or control meaningful inventory, market, credit or obsolescence risks.

The transfer does not displace a more profitable third-party sale.

The supplier derives a sufficiently identifiable commercial benefit from facilitating the arrangement.

Even where these factors exist, “at cost” should not be treated as a default policy. The taxpayer should be able to demonstrate why an independent enterprise would accept no separate return in the particular circumstances.

It is also important to distinguish the cost of the product from any additional activities. Even if the product itself is passed through without a markup, an arm’s-length fee may still be required for procurement, handling, warehousing or logistics services performed by the supplying entity.


When would compensation generally be expected?

Compensation is more likely to be required where the supplying entity operates as a distributor or otherwise contributes commercial value to the transaction. This may be the case where it:

Purchases and holds inventory for its own business.

Performs procurement, quality-control, warehousing or logistics functions.

Controls and bears inventory, market, credit or obsolescence risks.

Regularly supplies products to the related party.

Transfers scarce or strategically important inventory.

Gives up an alternative third-party sale or another commercially attractive opportunity.

In these circumstances, an independent supplier would ordinarily seek an appropriate return.

That return should not automatically be expressed as a standard markup on cost. Depending on the facts and available comparables, an appropriate transfer pricing method could involve a comparable uncontrolled price, a resale-price analysis, a transactional net margin method or another method capable of producing an arm’s-length outcome.

The strategic question is therefore not simply whether a markup applies, but how the available return should be allocated across the value chain.


Competitiveness does not override the arm’s-length principle

A frequent concern is that a markup charged by the supplying entity will increase the receiving entity’s product cost and make the final selling price uncompetitive.

This is commercially relevant, but it does not establish that the supplier should earn no return. Nor should the transfer price be determined solely by the amount of profit the receiving entity needs to retain. Instead, the group should examine why the value chain cannot support the returns that the entities would ordinarily expect. For example:

Have market prices declined?

Are excess logistics or procurement costs being incurred?

Is obsolete or slow-moving inventory involved?

Which entity controls the pricing strategy and bears the associated market risk?

Would independent parties renegotiate the price, share the loss or decline the transaction?

These questions help determine whether lower profitability reflects market conditions, the allocation of risk or an underlying weakness in the group’s operating model.

Where the transaction generates an overall loss, that loss should not automatically be placed with whichever entity can most easily absorb it. It should be allocated consistently with the parties’ conduct, risk control and realistic commercial alternatives.


Documentation requirements

A short agreement and an invoice at cost will rarely provide sufficient support on their own. Contemporaneous documentation should explain:

The event that created the need for the transfer.

Whether the arrangement was exceptional or recurring.

How the inventory was originally sourced and held.

The functions performed and risks controlled by each entity.

Whether the supplier gave up alternative sales opportunities.

The pricing method selected and the evidence supporting it.

How the transaction affected the profitability of both entities.

Internal correspondence, inventory records, customer forecasts, procurement data and evidence of third-party pricing may be particularly valuable. Where a group repeatedly relies on “temporary” transfers, tax authorities may reasonably question whether the arrangement has become part of the group’s normal distribution model.

For cross-border transactions, businesses should also consider whether the transfer pricing outcome is aligned with customs valuations, indirect tax treatment and the entities’ accounting records. Inconsistent positions across these areas may attract additional scrutiny.


Key takeaway

Intercompany inventory transfers should not be approached through a blanket “cost” or “cost-plus” policy.

A transfer at cost may be defensible where the supplier performs a genuinely limited role, assumes no meaningful risk and does not give up a valuable commercial opportunity. Where the supplier performs distribution functions, controls relevant risks or transfers inventory from its ordinary business, an arm’s-length return will generally need to be considered.

The strongest position is one in which the pricing follows the commercial reality of the transaction and the documentation demonstrates why independent parties would have reached a comparable outcome.

As transfer pricing scrutiny develops under the UAE Corporate Tax regime, businesses should treat exceptional inventory movements as pricing and governance decisions, rather than merely operational adjustments.

GCC tax

GCC Tax Monday is a weekly publication that provides valuable insights into tax developments across the GCC region. Each week, we cover key updates, regulatory changes, and expert analyses to keep you informed and prepared for the evolving tax landscape.
Alessandro Valente
Alessandro Valente
Partner - International Tax & Transfer Pricing
Rakesh Nair
Rakesh Nair
Partner - Corporate & International Tax
Deepak Variyam
Deepak Variyam 
Director - Indirect tax
Rishab Jalan
Rishab Jalan
Director - Corporate Tax
Nidhin Noufal
Nidhin Noufal
Senior Manager – International Tax and Transfer Pricing
Umais Butt
Umais Butt
Senior Manager - Indirect Tax