All individuals are required to determine their country of residence for income tax purposes when filing their personal tax returns. In most countries, including Canada, an individual is subject to tax on their worldwide income in the country in which they reside. While an individual’s residency is a simple determination for many, residency can be difficult to determine if one studies abroad, owns foreign personal property, has family and friends living around the world, and where one spends significant time in multiple countries.
A taxpayer’s residency status can also be challenged by the Canada Revenue Agency (“CRA”) or another foreign government agency, so it is important that the taxpayer consider all of the facts to appropriately determine their country of residence for income tax purposes. Below, we will briefly outline when the CRA may consider an individual to be a resident of Canada. We will also outline the implications where Canada and another country take the view that an individual is resident of each of the respective countries under each country’s domestic rules.
Under Canada’s domestic rules, an individual can be factually resident of Canada or deemed to be resident of Canada:
An individual will typically be considered a resident of Canada where they have “significant” residential ties to Canada. The CRA considers the following residential ties to be “significant”:
If, for instance, an individual owns or rents a home in Canada for personal use, and their family resides in Canada, that individual would normally be considered a factual resident of Canada for income tax purposes.
The CRA may also consider secondary ties (i.e., employment in Canada, personal property in Canada, a Canadian passport, a Canadian driver’s license, Canadian medical coverage, etc.) in determining whether an individual is factually a resident of Canada. However, these secondary ties are of less importance. Typically, one single secondary tie to Canada is usually not enough to establish that a taxpayer is factually resident of Canada.
In instances where an individual is considered to be a factual or deemed resident of Canada in a year under Canada’s domestic rules and is also considered to be resident of another country under that country’s domestic rules, the tiebreaker rules in the applicable tax treaty between Canada and the other country will need to be reviewed to determine the individual’s country of residence.
For example, the tax treaty between Canada and the United States of America (the “US”) provides that an individual’s country of residence is determined as follows:
The tests noted above are not always a simple determination, and usually require further guidance. There have been a number of court cases along with commentary that has been provided by the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (“OECD”) that aid in the interpretation of the above noted tests.
The tax treaty between Canada and the US therefore ensures that individuals are not subject to worldwide taxation in both Canada and the United States, as this would otherwise result in double taxation.
Note that the tests also vary amongst different tax treaties.
Specific professional advice should be obtained prior to the implementation of any suggestion contained in this article. Contact your Crowe Soberman advisor for more information.
Related Posts
Contact Us