Whisky casks

Whisky Sour

Caveat Emptor

Phil Smithyes, Managing Director
09/04/2025
Whisky casks
The one saying that has stood the test of time is ‘if it seems too good to be true, it probably is’ and it is important to pay heed to this at a time where research shows that one person falls victim to a scam every 10 seconds in the UK.

At Crowe Financial Planning we have lots of exciting ‘opportunities’ come across our desk, ranging from Kenyan Cotton Farms (a personal favourite of mine) through to new hotel complexes, built in far flung beach resorts across the globe. One thing they typically have in common is a headline of ‘secure’ or ‘low risk’ returns, typically of 15% upwards.

In a world where a ‘low risk’ typically results in a return of around 2%-4%, it is clear there is nothing low risk about any investment purporting to offer such high returns.

One investment that has come to the fore in recent years is investing in casks of whisky which, on the face of it, might have appeal. The advertisements are usually very slick, using names that may sound like long-established distilleries from the Scottish Highlands which can appear both plausible and appealing.

At the end of March, a BBC investigation revealed hundreds of people had been duped into ploughing their life savings and pensions into casks that were overpriced or did not exist, with investments running into millions.

It takes three years for spirit to become Scotch whisky in a cask, and investors are encouraged to keep barrels for up to 10 years or more to maximise returns. Projected returns started at 12% and were forecast to increase to as much as 50% over time.

Certificates showed where casks were stored but when the warehouses were contacted, low and behold they weren't there, and many investors lost most or all their money.

Like investing in wine, you should really know where you are investing and understand the quality and reputation of the distillery or vineyard. It is easy to get caught up in the excitement of such an opportunity, and they do say that with wine, you should buy two cases at a time: one for drinking and one for laying down for future sale.

As with many scams, it is important to do your research and due diligence prior to making any investment in such ‘assets’, or to employ the services of a professional broker or wine merchant, as it really is a case of ‘buyer beware’ when it comes to these types of investments.

In conclusion, while the allure of high returns can be tempting, it is crucial to remain vigilant and sceptical of any investment that promises guaranteed or exceptionally high returns. Always remember to:

  • verify the legitimacy of the investment and the entities involved
  • consult with financial advisors or professionals before committing your money
  • be wary of pressure tactics that urge you to invest quickly without thorough consideration.

By taking these precautions, you can better protect yourself from falling victim to scams and make more informed investment decisions. Remember, if something seems too good to be true, it probably is.

Meet our Financial Planning team
Helping secure your future financial objectives.

Disclaimers

Crowe Financial Planning UK Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (‘FCA’) to provide independent financial advice.

The information set out in this publication is for information purposes only and is based on our understanding of legislation, whether proposed or in force, and market practice at the time of writing. It does not constitute advice to undertake a particular transaction. Appropriate professional advice should be taken on specific issues before any course of action is pursued. Any advice provided by a Crowe Consultant will follow only after consideration of all aspects of our internal advice guidance.

Past performance is not a guide to future performance, nor a reliable indicator of future results or performance. The value of investments, and the income or capital entitlement which may derive from them, if any, may go down as well as up and is not guaranteed; therefore, investors may not get back the amount originally invested.

The Financial Conduct Authority does not regulate Trusts, Tax or Estate Planning.

Please be aware that by clicking onto any links to third party websites you will be leaving the Crowe Financial Planning website. Please note that Crowe Financial Planning is not responsible for the accuracy of the information contained within the linked sites.

Related insights

loading gif
Man on tablet smiling at another person in the office
Stopping withdrawals from your Discounted Gift Trust
Stopping withdrawals is not always straightforward. Explore your options, tax implications, and why expert advice is essential before making changes.
Handwatch- on - beach
Retirement needs planning
How will I know how much I will need in order to retire and how am I going to get there?
two ladies chatting with laptop
Investing showdown: Active vs Passive
We explain the advantages and the drawbacks of active and passive investing.
Two ladies looking laptop
How accountants and financial advisors help you achieve long-term financial success
Working with an accountant and financial advisor helps build a compliant, tax-efficient strategy for long-term financial success
woman on phone looking out of window
Your tolerance to investment risk and what it means
How comfortable are you with investment risk? Understanding your Investment risk is important in helping you achieve your financial goals.
woman paying on phone
Returning from a high-inflation economic environment
As the BOE prepares to potentially lower interest rates, savvy savers could/may significantly bolster their financial positions.
house sitting on desk
Inheritance Tax: Could it impact you?
With more estates being caught by Inheritance Tax, could it impact you and what are the allowances available?
Two hands writing on paper
What is a Paraplanner?
Paraplanners serve as a bridge between our client's financial goals and the strategies employed to achieve them.
person putting puzzle pieces together
Pension consolidation
With a ‘one pot pension for life’ on the horizon, we look at when pension consolidation may or may not be right for you.
two people running on beach
Investing: A marathon not a sprint
Investing isn’t a sprint — it’s a marathon. Long-term discipline, patience, and compounding are key to building lasting financial success.
Students writing
The ever-increasing costs of educating children
With university costs nearing £20,000 a year, early financial planning is key to easing the burden of tuition fees and student living expenses.
Tennis ball
Game, Set, Plan
Wimbledon wisdom: What tennis legends teach us about smart financial planning.
Man on tablet smiling at another person in the office
Stopping withdrawals from your Discounted Gift Trust
Stopping withdrawals is not always straightforward. Explore your options, tax implications, and why expert advice is essential before making changes.
Handwatch- on - beach
Retirement needs planning
How will I know how much I will need in order to retire and how am I going to get there?
two ladies chatting with laptop
Investing showdown: Active vs Passive
We explain the advantages and the drawbacks of active and passive investing.
Two ladies looking laptop
How accountants and financial advisors help you achieve long-term financial success
Working with an accountant and financial advisor helps build a compliant, tax-efficient strategy for long-term financial success
woman on phone looking out of window
Your tolerance to investment risk and what it means
How comfortable are you with investment risk? Understanding your Investment risk is important in helping you achieve your financial goals.
woman paying on phone
Returning from a high-inflation economic environment
As the BOE prepares to potentially lower interest rates, savvy savers could/may significantly bolster their financial positions.
house sitting on desk
Inheritance Tax: Could it impact you?
With more estates being caught by Inheritance Tax, could it impact you and what are the allowances available?
Two hands writing on paper
What is a Paraplanner?
Paraplanners serve as a bridge between our client's financial goals and the strategies employed to achieve them.
person putting puzzle pieces together
Pension consolidation
With a ‘one pot pension for life’ on the horizon, we look at when pension consolidation may or may not be right for you.
two people running on beach
Investing: A marathon not a sprint
Investing isn’t a sprint — it’s a marathon. Long-term discipline, patience, and compounding are key to building lasting financial success.
Students writing
The ever-increasing costs of educating children
With university costs nearing £20,000 a year, early financial planning is key to easing the burden of tuition fees and student living expenses.
Tennis ball
Game, Set, Plan
Wimbledon wisdom: What tennis legends teach us about smart financial planning.