Subscribe to Take Into Account knowledge hub
Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) Topic 323, “Investments – Equity Method and Joint Ventures,” provides guidance on accounting for investments in entities over which an investor has significant influence but does not have a controlling financial interest.
Under current guidance, the threshold for applying the equity method depends on the legal form of the investee. For investments in common stock or in-substance common stock of corporations and similar entities, significant influence is presumed to exist when an investor holds 20% or more of an investee’s voting stock, unless predominant evidence indicates otherwise. Conversely, an investor holding less than 20% of the voting stock is presumed not to have significant influence unless that influence can be demonstrated.
For investments in partnerships and similar entities, including certain limited liability companies (LLCs), equity method accounting generally is required when an investor’s interest is more than minor. In practice, ownership interests exceeding approximately 3% to 5% typically are deemed to be more than minor and, therefore, generally require application of the equity method.
These differing thresholds can result in investments with similar economic characteristics being accounted for differently solely because of an investee’s legal structure.
Stakeholders also have identified challenges in accounting for investments with complex allocation structures, such as partnerships that distribute earnings or cash through contractual distribution waterfalls. Although ASC 970-323, “Real Estate – General – Investments – Equity Method and Joint Ventures,” includes guidance for these arrangements, ASC 323-10 does not explicitly address how to allocate earnings in complex structures outside the real estate industry.
In response to stakeholder feedback received during its 2025 agenda consultation, the FASB developed targeted amendments intended to improve consistency, comparability, and the operability of equity method accounting.
The proposed ASU would require investors to apply a single significant influence threshold when determining if an unconsolidated investment should be accounted for under the equity method, regardless of whether the investee is organized as a corporation, a partnership, an unincorporated joint venture, or an LLC.
For investments in corporations, the proposed amendments would retain the existing requirement that an investment represent common stock or in-substance common stock to qualify for the equity method. The proposal would not extend the in-substance common stock guidance to investments in partnerships and similar entities.
Under the proposed guidance, an investor in a partnership or similar entity would apply equity method accounting only when it has the ability to exercise significant influence over the investee’s operating and financial policies. Investments that do not qualify for the equity method would generally be accounted for under ASC 321, “Investments – Equity Securities.”
Crowe observation: The proposed changes could have a significant impact on entities holding noncontrolling interests in partnerships and LLCs that currently apply the equity method based on the more-than-minor threshold. Investors with relatively small passive interests might no longer qualify for equity method accounting and, as such, might be required to measure those investments under ASC 321.
The proposed amendments also would modify the guidance in ASC 323-10 for assessing whether an investor has significant influence.
Specifically, the amendments would:
The other existing indicators of significant influence would remain relevant, including participation in policymaking processes, material transactions between the investor and investee, interchange of managerial personnel, technological dependency, and the investor’s relative ownership concentration.
Crowe observation: For investments in partnerships and LLCs, the evaluation of significant influence would place greater emphasis on the investor’s substantive governance and decision-making rights. Investors should review partnership agreements, operating agreements, and other contractual arrangements carefully to determine whether the investors can participate in the investee’s significant operating and financial policy decisions. These assessments might require consideration of management agreements, side agreements, and other contractual arrangements rather than relying exclusively on an investment’s ownership percentage.
The proposed ASU also would clarify how investors determine their share of an investee’s earnings when contractual arrangements provide for allocations that differ from ownership percentages.
Complex allocation structures can include preferential returns, disproportionate allocations of profits and losses, distribution waterfalls, and changes in allocation percentages upon the occurrence of specified events.
Under current guidance, ASC 970-323 requires investors in real estate ventures to consider the economic substance of such arrangements when determining their share of an investee’s earnings. Specifically, investors must consider how changes in the investee’s net assets, determined in accordance with GAAP, would affect distributions during the investee’s life and upon liquidation.
The proposed ASU would relocate that guidance to ASC 323-10, making it explicitly applicable to equity method investments in both real estate and non-real-estate entities.
The amendments would clarify that specified profit and loss allocation ratios should not be used to determine an investor’s equity in earnings when the allocation of cash and liquidation distributions is determined on another basis.
Crowe observation: Investors should not assume that their share of an investee’s earnings necessarily equals their percentage ownership. Entities should consider whether their existing allocation methodologies appropriately reflect the substance of the arrangement, particularly when preferential distributions or other complex economic terms are present.
The proposed ASU would add two illustrative examples to ASC 323-10, each one demonstrating a possible method for allocating earnings in complex structures.
The first example illustrates an investment in a limited partnership with preferential capital returns and cumulative annual returns. The example demonstrates how changes in each investor’s claim to the investee’s net assets, adjusted for contributions and distributions, can be used to determine equity in earnings.
The second example illustrates a similar approach for an investment in a corporation with preferential economic rights and a difference between the investor’s cost basis and its share of the investee’s underlying net assets.
Each example demonstrates an approach similar to the hypothetical liquidation at book value (HLBV) method, which commonly is used in practice to allocate earnings in complex investment structures.
Under HLBV, an investor generally determines its share of earnings by considering changes in its claim to the investee’s net assets, assuming the investee’s assets and liabilities are liquidated at their GAAP carrying amounts.
The FASB specifically noted that the examples each illustrate one possible methodology rather than the only acceptable approach. Other methods might be appropriate when they better reflect the economic substance of the arrangement.
Crowe observation: For entities using HLBV or similar methodologies, the proposed amendments present an opportunity to assess whether existing calculation models adequately capture the terms of the underlying investment agreements. Particular attention should be given to cumulative preferred returns, changes in distribution priorities, capital contributions, and investor-specific basis differences.
The proposed ASU also would make several consequential amendments to other areas of GAAP.
Under current GAAP, proportionate consolidation is permitted in limited circumstances for certain unconsolidated investments in unincorporated entities in the construction and extractive industries that otherwise qualify for equity method accounting.
The proposed amendments would preserve the ability to apply proportionate consolidation to qualifying investments in those industries, even when an investor does not have significant influence under the new threshold. This also could expand eligibility to certain investments that do not meet the current more-than-minor threshold.
Crowe observation: The proposal would continue to restrict proportionate consolidation to eligible investments in the construction and extractive industries. Entities should continue to evaluate the specific industry and investment eligibility requirements before applying proportionate consolidation. The proposal would not change the requirements for proportionate consolidation of investments in real property owned by undivided interests.
The proposed amendments also would clarify the interaction between ASC 323 and the proportional amortization method (PAM) in ASC 740-323, “Income Taxes – Investments – Equity Method and Joint Ventures.”
Under the proposal, an entity would first assess whether an unconsolidated equity investment that generates income tax credits and other income tax benefits qualifies for PAM and, if so, whether the entity elects to apply PAM. If the investment does not qualify for PAM or the entity elects not to apply it, the entity would then evaluate the investment under other generally accepted accounting principles, including the equity method.
Crowe observation: For purposes of applying PAM, an investor has significant influence if it can influence the operating or financial policies of the underlying project. The investor evaluates that influence using the qualitative indicators in ASC 323-10-15-6 and 15-7; it does not apply quantitative ownership thresholds. Accordingly, the proposed changes to the quantitative assessment of significant influence are not expected to affect PAM eligibility.
The proposed ASU also would amend ASC 810 to require entities to consider the complex allocation guidance in ASC 323 when allocating income to noncontrolling interests in consolidated subsidiaries.
The amendments are intended to provide an authoritative basis for allocating income in consolidated entities with complex ownership and distribution arrangements.
The proposed guidance would require entities to consider differences between applying the equity method and preparing consolidated financial statements. Specifically, the investor-specific equity method basis-difference accounting illustrated in the proposed ASC 323 example would not be applicable when allocating income to noncontrolling interests in consolidated subsidiaries.
Crowe observation: While entities frequently apply the complex allocation guidance by analogy when allocating income to noncontrolling interests under current GAAP, the proposed amendments could affect how some entities attribute income to noncontrolling interests when contractual distribution arrangements do not align with ownership percentages. Changes in the attribution of consolidated earnings could affect net income attributable to the parent and, for entities reporting earnings per share, related per-share amounts.
The proposal would remove certain industry-specific guidance in ASC 970-810 governing consolidation of real estate ventures and instead require entities to evaluate those investments under the general consolidation guidance in ASC 810.
It also would relocate other guidance currently included in ASC 970-323 that is not specific to the real estate industry. These provisions include guidance addressing certain intra-entity transactions, recognition of investee losses, obligations to provide additional financial support, and circumstances in which other investors cannot bear their share of losses.
Additional conforming amendments would update guidance for not-for-profit entities and not-for-profit business-oriented healthcare entities in ASC 958-810 and ASC 954-810, respectively, to reflect the proposed changes to the equity method threshold and related consolidation guidance.
The FASB will determine the effective date of the proposed ASU after considering stakeholder feedback. The proposed transition requirements would vary depending on the specific amendments, as described here.
For amendments related to the scope of ASC 323, the transition method would depend on whether an investment that no longer qualifies for equity method accounting is accounted for under the measurement alternative in ASC 321 on the date of adoption.
The measurement alternative is available for certain equity securities without readily determinable fair values. Under that alternative, investments generally are measured at cost less impairment, adjusted for observable price changes in orderly transactions involving identical or similar investments of the same issuer.
For investments for which an entity elects and applies the measurement alternative at adoption, the proposed amendments would require a modified prospective approach such that the carrying amount of the equity method investment on the adoption date would become its new cost basis under ASC 321.
For investments for which an entity does not apply the measurement alternative at adoption, entities would apply a modified retrospective approach. Under this approach, entities would recognize a cumulative-effect adjustment to opening retained earnings, or another appropriate component of equity or net assets, calculated as the difference between the investment’s fair value and its carrying amount at the date of adoption.
For amendments related to complex allocation structures, entities would apply the new guidance prospectively to both new and existing investments beginning on the adoption date.
For amendments related to the scope of ASC 323, entities would be required to disclose the nature of and reason for the change in accounting principle and, when applicable, the cumulative effect on opening retained earnings or other appropriate components of equity or net assets.
For amendments related to complex allocation structures, entities would be required to disclose the nature of and reason for the change in accounting principle.
For both sets of amendments, the respective disclosures would be required in the interim reporting period, if applicable, and the annual reporting period in which the amendments are adopted.
Early adoption would be permitted in an interim or annual reporting period for which financial statements have not yet been issued or made available for issuance. Entities adopting the amendments during an interim period would be required to apply them as of the beginning of the annual reporting period that includes that interim period.
Comments are due Jan. 11, 2027.
FASB materials reprinted with permission. Copyright 2026 by Financial Accounting Foundation, Norwalk, Connecticut. Copyright 1974-1980 by American Institute of Certified Public Accountants.