CHICAGO – As COVID-19 cases across the United States spiked in mid-July, executives expressed significantly more concern than just a few weeks prior, according to data from the new report, “Crowe Business Challenges Survey: Part II.” Sixty-eight percent of respondents in the last weeks of July noted high concern about the pandemic, up from just 51% a few weeks earlier, a 17-point jump.
Crowe, a public accounting, consulting and technology firm in the U.S. with offices around the world, conducted a pulse survey of 349 C-suite executives in three phases between late June and mid-August 2020 for the second report in the firm’s ongoing research series. The first report examined sentiment between late April and early June. The research series compiles responses from leadership spanning industries such as the public sector, financial services, construction, healthcare and manufacturing and distribution. The second report analyzes respondents’ evolving uncertainty and pessimism, the remote-work transition, and organizations’ top concerns and actions taken – including assessments on how their businesses and the government are navigating important social issues.
This survey’s second phase occurred from July 15 to Aug. 1, which coincided with a nationwide resurgence of the coronavirus. In addition to increased concern about the pandemic during this phase, respondents also grew more pessimistic about the overall economy – 49% were somewhat or very pessimistic in the survey’s first phase, while 54% said as much in the second. Respondents also reported more high uncertainty within their organizations in the second phase – 28% compared with 22% in the previous phase. Worries about a second wave of COVID-19 have remained largely static, but high, with 85% of respondents at least moderately concerned about a potential second wave.
“In July, as some restrictions were loosened and the virus spiked, it became clear how closely the economic recovery is tied to public health,” said Ann Lathrop, chief marketing officer at Crowe. “Organizational decision-makers were navigating whether or not to open their offices, facilities, schools or universities. They faced very tough and complex decisions balancing the health of their people with financial resiliency. Our data shows that worry, concern and uncertainty remained the norm for executives this summer.” When asked how much uncertainty their organization is dealing with, 24% responded with high uncertainty, 60% with moderate uncertainly and only 16% reported minimal uncertainly.
In the first report of this research series, 43% of respondents expected COVID-19’s effects on their organization to meaningfully decline by the end of 2020. However, by the second report reality appeared to sink in, and that optimism withered with only 12% of respondents now predicting 2020 for organizational recovery.
The survey also asked how respondents would rate their organization’s response to several social issues. More than half of respondents rated their organization’s responses to both racial injustice and social inequality as excellent or good. “Following the events that magnified nationwide racial inequity this spring and summer, many companies, including Crowe, were compelled to speak out, take a stance or address how they can fight against racial injustice within their own organizations. Even if those actions are in early stages, the fact that companies are addressing systemic problems appears to be making an impression,” added Lathrop.
Other key report findings include:
The report also specifically looks at the public sector services industry, including respondents from government entities, higher education institutions and not-for-profit organizations. Public sector respondents usually were about 10 percentage points more uncertain (or outright pessimistic) about the pandemic’s effect on their organizations than respondents in general.
“Public sector employees are on the front lines of the pandemic,” said Kevin Smith, managing partner of the public sector services group at Crowe. “The decisions about whether or not to open schools and universities or lift pandemic restrictions impact not only their organizations but the public as a whole. Additionally, economic struggles usually hit the sector at least a year later, after tax revenues, tuition fees and charitable donation decline, so it’s not surprising this group is notably more uncertain or pessimistic.”
Additional key findings from the public sector include:
A piece of good news for the public sector is that its transition to remote work seems to have been both sweeping and effective. Thirty-one percent of public sector respondents said their organizations shifted completely to a remote workforce as a result of COVID-19, much higher than all respondents. When asked how the shift to remote work went, 53% of public sector respondents rated it as excellent. “The public sector likely did well here because many had to embrace technology after cost-cutting measures following the Great Recession, meaning processes and systems that made remote work easier were already in place,” added Smith.
For additional survey findings, please visit Crowe business challenges survey.
About the Crowe Business Challenges Survey: Part II
The “Crowe Business Challenges Survey: Part II” was conducted in separate phases between late June and mid-August 2020. There were 121 responses in the first phase, 117 in the second phase and 111 in the third. Respondents represented such industries as financial services, manufacturing and distribution, construction, healthcare and the public sector. Respondents included members of the C-suite, such as CEOs, CFOs, presidents, senior vice presidents, directors and board members. For some questions, results exceed 100% due to rounding or because respondents could select more than one answer.
Crowe LLP is a public accounting, consulting and technology firm with offices around the world. Crowe uses its deep industry expertise to provide audit services to public and private entities. The firm and its subsidiaries also help clients make smart decisions that lead to lasting value with its tax, advisory and consulting services. Crowe is recognized by many organizations as one of the best places to work in the U.S. As an independent member of Crowe Global, one of the largest global accounting networks in the world, Crowe serves clients worldwide. The network consists of more than 200 independent accounting and advisory services firms in more than 130 countries around the world.